A
Romance delivers intense chemistry, deeply developed characters, a compelling plot, heart-melting moments, perfectly balanced steam, and unforgettable re-readability—an absolute must-read.
B
Romance delivers likable characters, engaging chemistry, and satisfying steam, though it leans on common tropes and lacks deep emotional impact, making it enjoyable but not unforgettable.
C
Romance is mildly entertaining but lacks depth, spark, and originality, with clichéd conflict, shallow characters, and forgettable chemistry, and not leaving a lasting impression.
D
Romance lacks chemistry, depth, and emotional connection, with forced relationships, flat characters, and weak plotting, making it frustrating and entirely forgettable.
